Search: palestine icc
14 Apr ICC Prosecutor Symposium: Wanted–International Prosecutor to Deliver Justice Successfully Across Multiple Complex Situations with Inadequate Resources
[Jonathan O’Donohue is a consultant on international justice and human rights, formerly a Legal Advisor at Amnesty International. Be sure to also read Ewan Brown and William H. Wiley at Justice in Conflict.] The vacancy announcement circulated globally in August last year emphasizes the extensive skills and experience that the next International Criminal Court (ICC) Prosecutor must bring to the role but makes no mention of the serious resource challenges the successful candidate will face when they take office. The budget of the ICC Office of the Prosecutor (OTP) for...10 Feb Protesting Too Much About Samantha Power and the ICC
...is not because an ad hoc would do a better job (an argument that Power does an excellent job in debunking) but because, essentially, we don’t like the ICC. Moreover, regarding the torture in Abu Ghraib and the (ever increasing) allegations about Guantanamo, one should note that the reason the ICC prosecutor isn’t investigating is because the prosecutor himself does not believe the ICC has jurisdcition over any of these claims. If the ICC actually was some out-of-control international tribunal, as the over-heated rhetoric of some of the its detractors...
31 Jul Crime of Aggression Negotiations Blocked by France, the United Kingdom, and Canada
and conditions for the ICC’s exercise of jurisdiction over it had to be negotiated later (Rome Statute Art 5.2.) When agreement on those was reached by consensus of all ICC States Parties in 2010 (see Kampala resolution), the crime—largely at the insistence of the United States—was made subject to an exceptional jurisdictional regime that significantly reduces the ability of the ICC to investigate or prosecute the crime. (For details, see Trahan, Reisinger Coracini, McDougall here and here.) Further restrictions were placed, or arguably placed, on the ICC‘s exercise of jurisdiction as...
07 Oct Symposium on Gender Representation: The International Criminal Court’s “Boys Club” Problem
of State or their Minister of Foreign Affairs. Efforts to address the national level gender imbalance must continue but it is incumbent upon ASP representatives to proactively make decisions that reflect an appreciation for gender balance when appointing members to committees or groups. ICC Staff At the Court itself, according to the 2020 Report of the Bureau on Equitable Geographical Representation and Gender Balance in the Recruitment of Staff of the ICC (Gender and Geographical Representation Report), as of 30 September 2020, the ICC staff was 49.2 percent female and...06 Sep Why Kenya Won’t Withdraw from the ICC
There has been much consternation and hand-wringing about the Kenyan parliament’s decision to table a motion to withdraw from the ICC. I understand the fear; Kenya’s withdrawal would obviously be a sign that Kenyatta and Ruto no longer intend to cooperate with the Court. Withdrawal could also encourage other African states to leave the ICC, which they have not seemed particularly keen to do, despite their incessant protests that the Court is little more than a neo-colonial instrument of the West that is (in one memorable description) “hunting” Africa. That...
11 Oct The Use of AI at the ICC: Should we Have Concerns? Part II
[ Gabrielle McIntyre is Chair of Women’s Initiatives for Gender Justice, Co-cordinator of Africa Legal Aid’s Gender Mentoring Programme for International Judges; Independent international law consultant. Nicholas Vialle is a Pro Bono Lawyer (human rights, refugee and migration law), Australia; Independent international human rights law consultant.] This brings us to the second issue concerning the development of AI which may raise issues of concern at the ICC particularly in relation to commitments to gender equality and non-discrimination, which are at the core of the cultural framework of the ICC and...09 Oct Revisiting the Peace-Justice Debate in northern Uganda
...which point the ICC cannot investigate. This, however, brings up its own political problem for the ICC: should the Court investigate crimes committed in conflicts with origins and dynamics reaching far before 2002? As I have argued before, the ICC should think twice about investigating situations with roots long before July 1st 2002. If the ICC is understood as an institution which needs both legal and political legitimacy in order to be successful, investigating only the last bits of a conflict may be a recipe for disaster. It may make...30 Jun ICC Labor Woes Part II: What’s Two Million Euros Between Friends?
To date, the former Registrar’s actions have cost the ICC at least €855,000. And an informed source says there are approximately 15 more ReVision complaints pending, which the Court can obviously expect to lose. So the Registrar’s actions — almost always in defiance of the ICC’s own Appeals Board — could end up costing the Court more than €2,000,000. At a time when the ICC is already facing a significant budget crunch, that’s horrific. The ICC elected a new Registrar on 28 March 2018. We can only hope his personnel...