19 Nov What the London Convention and Protocol’s New Assessment Frameworks Mean for Marine Geoengineering Governance
[Stephanie Prufer J.D. has a Juris Doctor from Yale Law School and a Master in Environmental Management from the Yale School of the Environment. She was involved in negotiations at the London Convention and London Protocol, and Agreement under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea on the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Marine Biological Diversity of Areas beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ Agreement). She also interned at the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea.
Dr James Kerry is Chief Scientist at OceanCare and an adjunct Senior Research Fellow at James Cook University. He was involved in negotiations at the London Convention and London Protocol on marine geoengineering.]
The London Convention and London Protocol (together, LC/LP) are the treaties that protect the marine environment from the dumping of wastes and other matter at sea. In early October, Parties to the LC/LP adopted three Assessment Frameworks (AFs) for proposed ocean-climate interventions, referred to by the LC/LP as “marine geoengineering.” The decision, reached at the International Maritime Organization in London, marks a major step forward in international efforts to safeguard the marine environment as research expands into ocean-climate interventions. Although the AFs are not themselves binding, this article argues that they may nonetheless shape how States meet their existing obligations under international law, notably their obligations of due diligence and the application of the precautionary principle. In particular, we argue that the recognition of all three AFs as “best available practice” potentially gives them legal significance beyond their non-binding status, helping to inform what States’ existing obligations may require in practice.
At this year’s LC/LP Governing Body meeting, via a resolution, the Parties adopted a Revised AF for Scientific Research Involving Ocean Fertilization (hereinafter, Revised Ocean Fertilization AF), along with two new AFs for scientific research in ocean alkalinity enhancement and biomass sinking. Each AF details procedures for evaluating the scientific justification, environmental risks, and uncertainties associated with the proposed research, and for determining whether the activities constitute legitimate scientific research and are consistent with the aims of the LC/LP. Together, these AFs provide detailed guidance for assessing the environmental risks and scientific uncertainties associated with marine geoengineering research and determining whether proposed activities constitute legitimate scientific research consistent with the aims of the LC/LP.
How Should LC/LP Parties Use the Ocean Fertilization Assessment Framework?
For almost two decades, Parties to the LC/LP have sought to regulate ocean fertilization. The LC/LP Parties first took up ocean fertilization, when they issued a “statement of concern” in 2007. In 2008, through a resolution, Parties agreed that ocean fertilization activities other than legitimate scientific research should not be allowed, and they directed the treaties’ Scientific Groups to develop an Assessment Framework for evaluating research proposals on a case-by-case basis. That framework was adopted in 2010 through Resolution LC-LP.2, as the Assessment Framework for Ocean Fertilization.
In 2013, Resolution LP.4(8) took the next step by proposing to amend the London Protocol to prohibit the placement of matter for marine geoengineering activities listed in Annex 4, which includes ocean fertilization, unless the listing provides that the activity can be authorized under a permit. The amendment also added Annex 5, which provides that activities listed in Annex 4 should be assessed using “specific assessment frameworks” tailored to each technique. To date, this amendment has not yet entered into force. Importantly, the 2013 resolution expressly reaffirmed the continued application of the 2008 and 2010 resolutions pending entry into force of the 2013 amendment.
Therefore, Parties to the LC/LP have not only agreed that ocean fertilization falls within the scope of the LC/LP through previous decisions but also have repeatedly established that only legitimate scientific research on ocean fertilization should move forward. These successive decisions establish an expectation that Contracting Parties apply the Revised Ocean Fertilization AF when assessing ocean fertilization research proposals, irrespective of whether the 2013 amendment has entered into force. While these resolutions are not themselves legally binding, they may help to define what due diligence requires under existing LC/LP obligations. A Party that authorizes such research without applying the Revised Ocean Fertilization AF, or undertaking an equivalent level of environmental assessment and precaution, could therefore face difficulties demonstrating that it has fulfilled its existing due diligence obligations.
How Should LC/LP Parties Use the Biomass Sinking and Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement Assessment Frameworks?
This year’s LC/LP resolution also adopted the Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement and Biomass Sinking AFs. It noted that Parties “may consider whether these frameworks should be applied as ‘specific assessment frameworks’ pursuant to article 6bis paragraph 2 of the 2013 amendment once it enters into force and if the respective [marine geoengineering] technique is listed in Annex 4.” (para. 2) The resolution further encouraged Parties to “assess scientific research proposals on a case-by-case basis using the respective Assessment Frameworks.” (para. 3)
For now, though, these AFs do not have binding legal force. The 2013 amendment proposed in Resolution LP.4(8) has not entered into force, and its Annex 4 does not list ocean alkalinity enhancement or biomass sinking. The 2008 and 2010 resolutions also do not mention either technique. Therefore, unlike the Revised Ocean Fertilization AF, these two frameworks have not been subject of earlier decisions expressly establishing that Parties should apply them. However, as the next section on “best available practice” examines, these AFs can be relevant for determining whether States have met their due diligence obligations under international law.
Moreover, Parties to the London Protocol that have accepted the 2013 amendment are obliged to refrain from acts that would defeat the object and purpose of the amendment before it enters into force, and may therefore have additional obligations, as long as the amendment’s entry into force has not been unduly delayed. (Vienna Convention on the Laws of Treaties, art.18(b)) The threshold for defeating an “object and purpose” is generally high, and several tests have been proposed. Here, the object and purpose of the amendment can be discerned from the 2013 London Protocol resolution, which expresses concern about the impacts of marine geoengineering activities and a desire to determine what constitutes legitimate scientific research. Failing to use the AFs would therefore likely not, on its own, violate the object and purpose of the amendment. Still, authorizing marine geoengineering activities without adequate precautionary assessment, particularly where doing so undermines the amendment’s environmental protections and regulatory objectives, could raise questions about whether a Party is defeating the amendment’s object and purpose. The recent adoption of the AFs reinforces the importance of precautionary assessment in the LC/LP, and provides clear guidance for evaluating proposed research activities in line with the environmental protection goals of the 2013 LP amendment.
What are the Implications of the Assessment Frameworks as “Best Available Practice”?
This year’s LC/LP resolution affirms that the AFs are considered “best available practice to determine, with utmost caution, whether the proposed activity constitutes legitimate scientific research and is not contrary to the aims of the London Protocol or the London Convention.” (para. 3) Although the frameworks differ in their history of endorsement and legal standing within the LC/LP, their recognition as “best available practice,” means that all three adopted AFs can inform whether Contracting Parties have met their due diligence obligations.
States are required, under customary international law and international treaties such as UNCLOS, to take measures to prevent and minimize harm to the environment of other States and areas beyond national jurisdiction. This is an obligation to act with due diligence. Due diligence is understood to require the adoption of reasonable measures, a level of vigilance in the enforcement of those measures, the exercise of administrative control such as monitoring of activities, and careful consideration of technology used. (ICJ Climate Change Advisory Opinion, para. 136; ITLOS Climate Change Advisory Opinion, para. 235) The standard of due diligence may also be more severe for riskier activities. (Responsibilities and Obligations of States with Respect to Activities in the Area, ITLOS Advisory Opinion, para. 117; ICJ Climate Change Advisory Opinion, para. 280) This means that a State must do what an informed actor would do in those circumstances, and courts and tribunals often look to external benchmarks to determine what is sufficient.
In its recent Climate Change Advisory Opinion, the ICJ looked at standards from binding sources (i.e., treaties and customary international law), and non-binding instruments to determine what due diligence requires. Both the ICJ and ITLOS noted in their advisory opinions on climate change obligations that due diligence is shaped by developments in law and practice. (ICJ Climate Change Advisory Opinion, para. 300; ITLOS Climate Change Advisory Opinion, para. 239) Similarly, in its Advisory Opinion on the Responsibilities and Obligations of States Sponsoring Persons and Entities with Respect to Activities in the Area, ITLOS noted that the content of due diligence can be informed by “best environmental practice.” (para. 136) Although the LC/LP resolution uses the term “best available practice” instead, this ITLOS advisory opinion supports the broader argument that internationally recognized practices can inform the standard of due diligence. Accordingly, the LC/LP AFs could provide an important benchmark for courts and tribunals assessing whether States have fulfilled their due diligence obligations in relation to marine geoengineering research activities under their jurisdiction or control.
It is important that this role is understood carefully. The ICJ and ITLOS, in their climate change advisory opinions, addressed general obligations under international law. The London Convention and London Protocol, by contrast, are treaty regimes with 87 and 56 Contracting Parties respectively, short of universal participation. Although the LC/LP have less than universal membership, the AFs may still be relevant beyond their Contracting Parties in that they provide guidance that can help inform how States meet their existing due diligence obligations under UNCLOS and customary international law.
Conclusion
The adoption of the three AFs in October marked real progress in the international governance of marine geoengineering. This year’s decisions reaffirm the established role of the Ocean Fertilization AF and set out agreed best available practice for assessing research proposals involving ocean alkalinity enhancement and biomass sinking. Importantly, they show that marine geoengineering research proposals do not exist in a governance vacuum. Although the AFs are not themselves legally binding, their recognition as best available practice gives them significance in assessing how States fulfil their existing due diligence obligations and the application of precaution.