Search: Affective Justice: Book Symposium: A Response
18 May Getting Ready for Next Time: The Work of the Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response
On 19 January 2021, the Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response (the “Panel”) presented to the WHO Executive Board its “Second Progress Report”, which is its first substantive report on its inquiry into the international response to the COVID-19 pandemic. While the Panel’s inquiry is still under way, it has submitted the Second Progress Report as an interim report consistent with its commitment to “work in an open and transparent fashion”. This post provides some observations on the Panel’s findings as well as its working methodology as reflected in...
07 Dec Advancing Human Rights in Pandemic Treaty Debates
...health emergency and pandemic prevention, preparedness and response. Find more information here or here. This is a pivotal moment in the global governance response to future pandemic threats, with crucial global health law reforms being undertaken through the World Health Organization (WHO) to “draft and negotiate a convention, agreement or other international instrument on pandemic preparedness and response.” To be developed by the World Health Assembly of WHO Member States, this so-called “Pandemic Treaty” provides a crucial opportunity to advance human rights in global health governance, responding to human rights...
16 Jun Is an Ineffective State Response to COVID-19 a Violation of Human Rights?
24; see also Poblete Vilches v. Chile). These human rights create a landscape in which States’ accountability for their response to COVID-19 can be adjudged upon. Ineffective State responses to the COVID-19 pandemic might not ostensibly go against international or regional human rights standards. However, when reviewed, violations of human rights become apparent. A common response by States that were ineffective in controlling the pandemic was a delayed response. The failure to act, especially when legally obligated to take measures to control and treat epidemics is a violation of Article...
23 Sep South-South Justice for Colombian Victims? Shedding Light on the (Limited) Potential of Universal Jurisdiction in Argentina
successful in maintaining the demands for justice for ‘false positives’ crimes as a relevant legal and political issue in Colombia. All in all, this and other UJ cases in Argentina are slowly opening new avenues for justice, albeit filled with challenges and uncertainties. For these reasons, we remain cautiously optimistic about its potential to become an example of South-South justice and will continue to focus on these cases to critically observe how human rights organizations, lawyers, victims and institutions continue to develop this legal practice against impunity of international crimes....
16 Dec Justice as Message Symposium: Expressivism as Bridging Theory
I I like the argumentive rigour of analytic philosophers, and I share the ideologicalsensitivities of most critical scholarship. But they largely appear as two different projects, studying different aspects of the elephant. Enter Carsten’s book on expressive theory. Carsten’s expressivist approach engages in open-minded inquiry into normativejustifications (hence he draws on Hegel, Duff and others). But he is equally curious about biases, shortcomings, and exclusions. If justice is a message, then what is the message, whose message is it, who transmits it, and to whom? Justice-as-message offers a framework that...
18 May Symposium on Systemic Racism and Sexism in Legal Academia: Beyond Diversity and Inclusion – How Global Human Rights Standards Might Inform Racial Justice Initiatives in Legal Education
It explains the importance of “comprehensive ‘whole-of-government’ and ‘whole-of-society’ reforms and responses to dismantle systemic racism, elaborated in comprehensive and adequately resourced national and regional action plans.” (A/HRC/47/53, Annex.) Thus, law schools can use a systemic approach, informed by human rights standards, to combat this scourge. Conclusion “Systemic racism needs a systemic response” proclaims the High Commissioner’s report. (A/HRC/47/53 ¶ 19.) International human rights standards offer actionable guidance for confronting racial injustice within law schools — beyond diversity and inclusion initiatives. As detailed above, these standards may inform efforts to...
14 Dec Justice as Message Symposium: What We See When We See Law … Through the Eyes of Dame Laura Knight
[ Diane Marie Amann is the Emily & Ernest Woodruff Chair in International Law and Faculty Co-Director of the Dean Rusk International Law Center at the University of Georgia School of Law.] The eye cannot help but be drawn to the cover of Justice as Message, the new analysis by Carsten Stahn of, to quote the subtitle, Expressivist Foundations of International Criminal Justice. On the high-gloss paper jacket we see a tableau of blacks and browns and olive drab, accented only by the purple of a lawyer’s robe and the...
18 Apr Symposium on Confronting Colonial Objects: Charting a Cultural Relational Justice – Unraveling the Complexity of Human Remains Restitution in the Democratic Republic of Congo
into account the needs articulated by the community? In this post, I will first examine the legal frames and challenges governing the restitution of human remains. I will pay particular attention to the case of the Wamba community, which calls into question conventional inter-state methodologies. I will then explore the potential of relational justice to mitigate dilemmas. 2. Moving Beyond the Interstate Approach: Towards Cultural Relational Justice The legal frameworks governing the restitution of human remains are sometimes complex and ambiguous. Among these texts, the 1970 Convention on the Prohibition...
12 Dec Why Individual Integrity Matters
integrity standards, how awareness of integrity can be raised, and what contributes to reinforcing an integrity mindset in staff and a culture of integrity in the agency in question” (page 40). Another recent publication, edited by Morten Bergsmo, Mark Klamberg, Kjersti Lohne and Christopher B. Mahony, Power in International Criminal Justice, further contributes to concretising what could be termed as an ‘integrity turn’ in international justice. In his introductory chapter, Bergsmo describes how a sociology of international criminal justice, unmasking power structures and informal social networks which may weaken institutional...
10 Jul Climate Justice in an Unequal World: A Chat with Professor Richard Falk, Ecocide’s Legal (Grand)Father
[Dr. Luigi Daniele is a Senior Lecturer at Nottingham Law School, NTU.] This interview is being cross-posted by Opinio Juris, the Nottingham Law School Climate Justice Hub , and the Queen Mary School of Law Centre for Climate Crime and Justice. I had the great honor and special pleasure of discussing ecocide and climate justice with Professor Richard Falk, Albert G. Milbank Emeritus Professor of International Law and Practice at Princeton University, Chair of Global Law and Co-director of the Centre for Climate Crime and Justice at Queen Mary University...