Search: Symposium on the Functional Approach to the Law of Occupation

acknowledge ambiguity than to ignore it, let alone to interpret it in favor of one's argument. Jordan Quite clearly, DPH conduct allows targeting under the laws of war (as DPAA woould under the law of self-defense). Whether CCF status allows targeting under the laws of war depends on the reach of dynamic customary int'l law, based on general patterns of practice and general patterns of opinio juris. We may be experiencing the creation of a new customary CCF norm. It would be helpful if there were more current studies of...

[Jean-Pierre Gauci is the Arthur Watts Senior Research Fellow in Public International Law at the British Institute of International and Comparative Law (UK) and the Director of The People for Change Foundation (Malta). Eleni Karageorgiou, is a Postdoctoral Fellow, Department of Law at Lund University and Researcher at the Raoul Wallenberg Institute of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law (Sweden).] Two shipwrecks close to the Libyan coast on 18 April 2015, which led to over 1,100 deaths followed by high numbers of refugee arrivals to Europe, mainly from Syria, resulted in...

...‘Right to Food’ Based Approach is Essential to Eradicate Hunger In light of the rights-based approach, hunger should be evaluated through the right to food, and in terms of the right to food, interstate cooperation is a legal responsibility to ensure socio-economic rights in accordance with Article 11(2) of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). The obligation to fulfill the right to food is divided into three sub-categories: (a) the obligation to facilitate, (b) the obligation to provide, and (c) the obligation to promote. Among these...

[ Donna Cline is a US-licensed criminal practitioner and lead for the Environment Mobile Justice Team at Global Rights Compliance, where she works closely with Ukrainian prosecutors to ensure accountability for war crimes. Julia Tétrault-Provencher is a Canadian lawyer (Quebec Bar) and international lawyer with the Sexual and Gender-Based Violence Mobile Justice Team at Global Rights Compliance in Ukraine.] Legal practitioners and scholars alike often remark that the environment is “the silent victim of war” (for instance here, here, or here). This saying is not without merit; thinking about the...

poses several risks to humanity and, particularly, to vulnerable groups, such as children, women and girls, and minorities, especially in the Global South. Furthermore, its risks in different critical civilian fields which have a direct impact on human rights, such as the law enforcement, administration of justice, and border control, environment, are already materializing. In the military domain, AI’s implications to international peace and security, have been discussed by the Group of Governmental Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (GGE on LAWS) of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW)...

...on the topic suggests that, although virtually all states require some form of legislative approach for some treaties, the diversity of approaches makes it difficult to create a uniform spectrum on one end of which the United States lies. For starters, Oona suggests that Tajikistan and the United States are “the only countries in the world that provide for less involvement by a part of the legislature in treaty-making than in domestic lawmaking and make the results of this process automatically part of domestic law . . .” (p. 37)...

the power of High Courts to grant any relief “… in relation to a person … who is for the time being subject to any laws relating to any of those Forces … in respect of any action taken in relation to him … as a person subject to such law.” Mr Jadhav is, of course, not a member of any armed forces of Pakistan, but for sure, he was subjected to Army Act, 1952 – a law relating to the armed forces of Pakistan. Fair Trial May Not Necessarily...

...the crime. Case law is peppered with discussion as to whether those who are hors de combat are “civilians” or constitute members of the “civilian population” for the purposes of crimes against humanity. Careful examination of this jurisprudence reveals that international criminal courts and tribunals, particularly the ad hoc tribunals, have taken different approaches to this issue. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia’s (ICTY) case law has taken a meandering path. Some cases have endeavoured to include those who are hors de combat within the notion of “civilian”...

[Pierre Bodeau-Livinec is Professor of Public Law at University Paris-Nanterre and the Managing Editor of The Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals.] As Kristen Boon very aptly points out, apologies given on December 1 by Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon for the role of the United Nations with regard to the cholera outbreak in Haiti can only be welcomed as a highly significant “change of direction” in the conduct adopted by the UN since 2010. At the same time, the Secretary-General’s statement and the report introducing “A new approach to...

[Richard H. Steinberg is Professor of Law at the University of California. Los Angeles; Visiting Professor of International, Comparative & Area Studies at Stanford University; and Director of the Sanela Diana Jenkins Human Rights Project.] I am grateful for Ian Hurd’s thoughtful comment on my book chapter partly because it supports my claim that that everyone borrows from the realist tradition. Moreover, Hurd’s comment inadvertently recapitulates a narrow structural realist view of international law (recalling the associated dysfunctional debate of the 1980s) that I intended my chapter to supersede, offering...

[ Megan Karlshøj-Pedersen is a Policy Specialist at Airwars, working across the U.K., U.S., the Netherlands and other European countries. Jessica Dorsey is an Assistant Professor of International and European Law at Utrecht University and the Managing Editor of Opinio Juris. Both authors are part of the civil society and academic consortium advising the Dutch Ministry of Defence described in this two-part post. Part II can be found here.] Over the last four years, a consortium of academic experts and civil society organisations has been engaging with the Dutch Ministry...

two would be an exaggeration. Jus cogens does not actually challenge positivism; on one possible interpretation, it can provide exception to the positivist criteria of law-making because it is public policy; on another interpretation, jus cogens actually conforms to the requirements of positive customary international law, but the constituents of customary law are then redefined in practice, again to conform to the public policy nature of jus cogens. These two explanations are not mutually exclusive. In more specific terms, the international tribunal’s consistent willingness to accept the customary law status...