IL and “The Death of Doctrinalism”
Interesting exchange kicked off by Einer Elhauge over at VC (here), with responses from Larry Tribe, Jack Balkin, and Orin Kerr (here, here, and here), among others, the basic line of which is that doctrinalism will get you nowhere in the legal academy these days. The disagreement has been mostly about what qualifies as doctrinalism, and whether this isn't...