21 Sep A Huge Loss at the Second Circuit for Chevron
New York – A federal appeals court vacated an order Monday by a New York judge that barred an $18 billion judgment in Ecuador against Chevron Inc. for contaminating the Amazon.
The three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had previously expressed skepticism that a New York judge could wield jurisdiction outside the U.S.
The lead lawyer for the plaintiffs, Pablo Fajardo, told The Associated Press by phone on Monday that they expected to be able to begin to collect by the first quarter of 2012 the damages that a Lago Agrio, Ecuador, court ordered Chevron to pay.
“We can now at least dream there will be justice and compensation for the damage, the environmental crime, committed by Chevron in Ecuador,” he said, adding that the decision “lets the world see that we are right, not just in Ecuador but in any court in the world.”
Representatives for the oil company did not immediately respond to requests for comment Monday.
Chevron has appealed the Lago Agrio decision, which was issued in February, and Fajardo said he expects an appeals court ruling in Ecuador in the next few months.
In New York, U.S. District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan had barred collection of the award, after determining that Chevron could prove that lawyers had manipulated a corrupt legal system in Ecuador to secure the judgment. The company had argued that the plaintiffs would collect the judgment before an appeals process was completed in Ecuador.
But a lawyer for the Ecuadorean plaintiffs told the appeals court in oral arguments Friday that they would not attempt to recover damages until the appeals process in Ecuador was completed.
The award followed nearly two decades of litigation.
When Kaplan issued his bizarre decision, I wondered what authority a U.S. judge had to interfere with Ecuador’s judicial process. (Can you imagine what the reaction would have been if the situation was reversed?) Apparently I wasn’t the only one who was skeptical.
There is still a long way to go legally, but this is an important step in holding Chevron accountable for the massive environmental damage it has caused to the Amazon rainforest.
For more information about what is referred to as Chevron’s “Rainforest Chernobyl” — the company deliberately dumped more than 18 billion gallons of toxic waste-water and spilled approximately 17 million gallons of crude oil in the area — see the ChevronToxico website here.