...for harmonized civil liability, the Omnibus defers entirely to national tort laws, where many Member States do not currently recognize a clear duty of care for extraterritorial harms. Additionally, the deletion of the provision enabling NGOs and trade unions to bring representative actions places the burden of initiating transnational litigation solely on individual victims—often rural communities, migrant workers, or Indigenous peoples lacking sufficient resources for protracted legal proceedings—and the absence of collective redress procedures under EU law further diminishes the likelihood of meaningful remedy. Misalignment with International Standards and Practices...
...agreement on modalities and a work plan. Divergence over the extraterritorial reach of human rights law, and State reluctance to confer anything resembling status on armed groups, were among the obstacles in both processes. A reform proposal has to engage with the record of the terrain it proposes to enter. We ask, what would make a treaty negotiation succeed where the 2012 and 2015 processes stopped short? And, which of the objections were principled and which merely convenient? Where the Gap Actually Lies We want to close constructively, because there...
...standards, the Commission addresses several other important aspects of the Charter’s application to the rights of Climate Migrants and Climate Refugees. First, the Guiding Principles affirm that, necessarily, migrants have a right to development that must include climate-resilient development ( Principle 32). The Commission thus urges States party to the Charter to take action to address the extraterritorial effects of climate change. And, in the context of the right to climate resilient development, second, the Commission notes that States must adopt mitigation measures in addition to adaptation and resilience strategies...
...contemporary realities are placing unprecedented strain on these foundations. Climate change threatening statehood; non-state actors exercising de facto territorial control; contested maritime and land boundaries; extraterritorial jurisdiction; and the enduring legacies/challenges of decolonisation and self-determination. In parallel, the prohibition on the use of force, the resilience of territorial integrity, and the role of international adjudication mechanisms in deciding territorial disputes are increasingly being tested by ongoing military conflicts and deeply contested geopolitical contexts. Against this backdrop, an overarching question emerges: Does international law’s understanding of territory remain fit for purpose...
...but did not have the authority to conduct prosecutions. Syrian civil society organizations, including victims’ groups, also played a critical role in gathering and analyzing information to support accountability and advance justice. With their help, European courts prosecuted some of these crimes under the principle of universal jurisdiction or other forms of extraterritorial jurisdiction. This has led to multiple trials that have so far been the only, though limited, justice avenues available to victims and survivors. The broader impact of impunity for crimes in Syria is evident. For example, the...
...region. See generally Ashley S. Deeks, “Unable or Unwilling”: Toward a Normative Framework for Extraterritorial Self-Defense, 52 Va. J. Int’l Law 483 (2012) (discussing the development and limitations of the unable and unwilling test); Essentially, the US is claiming that the invasion of Venezuela was legitimate self-defence because at the time of the invasion the government of Venezuela was led by Edmundo Gonzalez Urrutia, not Nicolas Maduro, and Gonzalez was unable to prevent Maduro from using Venezuelan territory to launch armed attacks against the US. A more bizarre invocation of...
...a sort of double standard in the enforcement of international law, which strikingly differs depending on whether the wrongdoer is a great power or one of its closest allies. Thirdly, other unilateral measures affecting global problems have multiplied despite clear-cut treaty prohibitions on them: the imposition of customs tariffs, the deportation of migrants, the extraterritorial arrest of drug traffickers and terrorists, the boost in greenhouse emissions, and the sanction of UN and ICC officials just for doing their job. Fourthly, an ever-growing number of states are withdrawing from, or hampering...
...international efforts focus primarily on preventing the effects of such threats, rather than on addressing the threats themselves or sanctioning them. There may be an implicit understanding that deviates from the stricter conclusions of the Nuclear Weapons Advisory Opinion. Specifically, the threat of force in response to the extrajudicial and extraterritorial killing of a high-ranking individual within domestic settings (even if they are considered leaders of terrorist organizations, such as Hamas, which is designated as a terrorist organization by the US and the EU) might be viewed as a proportionate...
...over territory. Furthermore, States must ensure their cyber capabilities and operations comply with existing international obligations, including human rights law, international humanitarian law, and treaty commitments. The extraterritorial application of human rights obligations takes on new dimensions when State surveillance technologies can monitor individuals globally or when State cyber operations affect critical infrastructure providing essential services. In December 2018, the UN General Assembly adopted the Eleven Norms of Responsible State behaviour in cyberspace. Although these norms are voluntary, they are based on international law obligations. However, it is concerning that...
...how India, Honduras, and Switzerland have introduced laws with an extraterritorial reach that clarify these states’ responsibilities for overseeing private security operations abroad. Finally, data protection principles and legislation are particularly relevant in controlling the data processing activities of PMSCs. Over 130 countries around the world have introduced data protection and privacy legislation that would be directly applicable to the companies operating in their jurisdiction. Also, the Council of Europe Convention 108 – officially titled ‘Convention for the Protection of Individuals with regard to Automatic Processing of Personal Data’ –...
...fear for their life. These evolving extraterritorial control mechanisms raise profound questions about the circumvention of established protection frameworks that have traditionally governed asylum policy. A Continuum of Externalization To understand the significance of this new “staging expulsion” model in the U.S., we must place it within a broader trend in migration governance: the externalization of migration control. Externalization refers to policies by which countries like the U.S., Australia or EU countries shift their migration enforcement responsibilities onto third countries – often in exchange for financial support, visa waivers or...
...born there, possessing no experience of life outside a detention environment. International law is unambiguous that they are victims, not security threats. The Convention on the Rights of the Child guarantees every child’s right to a nationality, to identity, and to have their best interests treated as a primary consideration. The Committee on the Rights of the Child has affirmed the extraterritorial reach of the Convention in the specific context of children detained in northeastern Syria. European courts have grappled with the implications. In September 2022, the Grand Chamber of...