The excitement over the AQ7 ad put out by Liz Cheney's organization has died down, but
Ben Wittes has this piece up in The New Republic extending the letter that he drafted, and to which I earlier linked, signed by a group of conservative and centrist folks criticizing it. I was one of the signers, and wound up sticking up by own very lengthy comment about it over at Volokh. I didn't link here at the time, as I thought the tone a little waspish for OJ, but with Ben's article in TNR, I'll
change my mind and link to it (it's long and the title is "No Righteous Gentile Award, Please").
I suppose the key point for Ben and me, in somewhat different ways, is that we have each received much praise from folks on the left for defending Obama lawyers such as Neal Katyal or Jen Daskal. No one objects to praise, or at least I don't, but much of it was a little misplaced. The praise tended to be as though, in order to defend the Obama lawyers, we had somehow changed our minds about the Bush lawyers. Whereas, for Ben and for me, each in somewhat different ways, the issue was the same. We defended Katyal and Daskal because we had defended the Bush lawyers and thought the same principle applied. I also followed up with an response to conservatives such as Andy McCarthy who attacked the Wittes letter; it too was fairly waspish in tone. What with health care reform, and lots of other things on the agenda, the discussion is moving on, but it has been an important one, and at least among conservatives, a clarifying one.
From the opening of Ben Wittes's essay:
