There has been tons of commentary on the pirate thing now, so there is little more to add. Except that there is a brewing debate about where to try the remaining captured Somali pirate. In theory, the pirate could be tried before a military commission, if Obama wished, but I somehow doubt that his going to happen (although if he...
A big case from the U.S. District Court here in New York came down this week, and I was spending my time reading blog posts on Harold Koh. Where are my priorities? In an important test of the scope of the Alien Tort Statute's application to multinational corporations, Judge Shira Scheindlin has finally ruled on the defendant corporations' motion to...
The folks at UN Dispatch say they have uncovered a conspiracy among conservatives to oppose Koh's nomination in what they describe is the "Dirty Fight Against Koh". The evidence is this draft letter to Senators Kerry and Lugar opposing Koh's confirmation. Thanks to Kevin's intervention, and Ed Whelan's gracious admission that he's gone a bit far in his rhetoric against his...
I have tried to stay quiet in the ongoing “Koh Wars” in the blogosphere, where Ed Whelan seems to be taking on the entire legal academic blogosphere himself and getting in a bad mood about it. I am also conflicted. I am a former student of Professor Koh and I have always admired his energy, passion, and his willingness to...
All news is local, I guess, even in this supposedly globalized age. So it is not surprising that it took an attack on a U.S. ship with a U.S. crew to focus the American public's attention on the piracy problem off the coast of Somalia. But as readers of this blog can attest, the piracy issue has been flagged, addressed,...
I was amused to read about the kerfuffle in the UK over the supposedly rude treatment UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown and his wife received during his recent White House visit. London newspapers are howling over a string of alleged snubs by Obama to British Prime Minister Gordon Brown during his visit to Washington last week — including a squabble over presidential...
Longtime readers know that I have been pretty skeptical of the usefulness of the ICC's actions against Sudan. Indeed, Professor Jide Nzelibe and I have argued in prior work that international criminal tribunals can worsen humanitarian atrocities rather than deter or prevent them, especially when they are aimed at leaders who have the power to commit greater atrocities to stay...
I've been critical of the Obama Administration's deceptive approach to war-on-terrorism legal issues (trash your predecessor, but endorse some of his key policies). But I don't have any real criticism of its latest decision to avoid the legal fight over the power to detain enemy combatants in the U.S. The Justice Department, in an abrupt change in policy from the Bush...
Again, this news is not exactly shocking: The Obama administration has told a federal judge that military detainees in Afghanistan have no legal right to challenge their imprisonment there, embracing a key argument of former President Bush’s legal team.In a two-sentence filing late Friday, the Justice Department said that the new administration had reviewed its position in a case brought by...
Belgium has filed a request for an order of provisional measures from the International Court of Justice against Senegal for that country's failure to prosecute former Chad dictator Hissene Habre. The press release describing Belgium's application lays out the legal theory, which boils down to: The Convention Against Torture and general international customary law. Belgium contends that under conventional international law, "Senegal’s...
It turns out conditions at the U.S. detention center in Guantanamo Bay do not violate U.S. obligations under Common Article III of the Geneva Conventions. So says a review of the detention center by the Pentagon that was ordered by President Obama. A Pentagon review of conditions in the Guantanamo Bay military prison has concluded that the treatment of detainees meets the...
As this BBC report suggests, investigating war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict is a pretty much hopeless task because there is no single entity with the expertise, knowledge, and legitimacy to find out the "truth." Any investigation, whether it is the UN or the ICC or Human Rights Watch, will be simply dismissed by the two sides as biased. So...
